Bill played defense for Episcopal Academy, graduating in 2012. He then attended Gettysburg College and walked on to the lacrosse team his freshman year under Hank Janczyk. During his time at Gettysburg he was a starter for their back-to-back Centennial Conference Championships and NCAA semifinals appearances. Additionally, he garnered All-American and Scholar All-American Honors his senior campaign.

Bill has coached with the NXT family since 2014 and enjoys using his knowledge of the game to develop youth players.